The Punisher (2004)
ABOUT
An ordinary lawman goes outside the law to carry out his own brand of justice in this dark-themed thriller. Frank Castle is an FBI agent who deeply loves his wife and son, but is also strongly devoted to his work. Castle’s investigation of a powerful crime cartel leads to a gunfight which claims the life of a young boy, whose father is underworld kingpin Howard Saint . Furious and eager for revenge, Saint arranges for Castle and his family to be murdered in retaliation. However, while Castle’s wife and son are killed, he somehow survives, even though he’s believed to have perished. Bent on stopping Saint once and for all, Castle remakes himself as The Punisher, a ruthless and heavily armed killing machine who will not rest until Saint and his crew have been wiped clean from the Earth.
DIRECTOR
Jonathan Hensleigh (Other works include “Kill the Irishman” and “Welcome to the Jungle”
STARRING
Thomas Jane as Frank Castle/Punisher (also starred in “The Mist”. “The Thin Red Line” and “Boogie Nights”)
John Travolta as Howard Saint (also starred in “Battlefield Earth”, “Hairspray” and “Face/Off”
Will Patton as Leonard Glass (also starred in “The Fourth Kind”, “Gone in 60 Seconds” and “Copycat”)
Roy Scheider as Mr. Castle (also starred in “Jaws “, “2010: The Year We Make Contact” and “Dracula II: Ascension”)
Laura Harring as Livia Saint, (also starred in “Silent Night, Deadly Night III: Better Watch Out!”, “All Souls Day” and “Willard”)
Ben Foster as Spacker Dave (also starred in “X-Men: The Last Stand”, “Prometheus” and “30 Days of Night”)
“The Punisher,” as a film, has plenty of potential. For those who have read the comic books and know what the Punisher is all about, this is probably the worst adaptation based upon a comic book. The Punisher isn’t supposed to have any humor. He is a dark, violent, anti-heroic vigilante.
When you need to make a successful movie about the Punisher, you need to preserve the general conceit of the Punisher ethos. 1) He’s insane. Anyone who kills for both a hobby and a living is crazy. 2) He’s only redeemed by the fact that the people he kills are worse than he is. MUCH worse. 3) Since he’s insane and cannot possibly coexist with society in a sane world, it’s nice to have some humor about the whole situation, just to keep some perspective on the issue and with luck, some major distance from any real-life “what-ifs”.
If you didn’t know the comic book …you probably could say that this movie was an OK movie. But, for me, I can’t overlook the fact that they failed to stick to the comic book version of the Punisher.
Simply put: Anyone who even remotely knows the character is infinitely better off seeing Punisher: War Zone instead, which actually depicts the character properly and doesn’t waste time with his origins.